The Apple Watch, available for pre-order April 10, will be a hit for one simple reason: It鈥檚 gorgeous.听
I continue to argue that people, even active, fitness-focused people, don鈥檛 want to wear clunky, ugly devices. We鈥檙e attracted to beauty in mates, in pets, in nature, and yes, even in what we buy. That鈥檚 one reason I鈥檓 such a fan of the Withings Activit茅 and Activit茅 Pop watches: they transition from the gym to the pub seamlessly.听
But they鈥檙e still not Apple. The Watch follows a line of illustrious products鈥攆rom the iMac to the iPhone to the iPad鈥攖hat have married design and function. Outr茅 looks sell, even if the rest of the device鈥檚 features match鈥攔ather than surpass鈥攖he competition.
That鈥檚 right. When it comes to fitness features, the debut Watch isn鈥檛 offering anything new. 听
It will use an arsenal of gyros and accelerometers to measure activity, and it can prompt you to move around if you鈥檙e being too sedentary, just like devices from Garmin and others can do. And like other wearables currently on the market (think the Mio Link or Fitbit Surge HR), the Watch also has a wrist-based heart-rate monitor that uses LEDs and photo sensors to detect pulse. This technology has improved in the last two years, but I鈥檝e found the best models still need to be worn tight (almost uncomfortably so), to avoid a shaky connection and inaccurate data. Perhaps Apple will prove (as Microsoft did with its Band) that better math will result in more accurate heart-rate tracking, but the technology isn’t new. 听
Monitoring heart rate is crucial for a few reasons. For one, it allows the Watch鈥檚 onboard activity ring to track metrics like calories burned and let. They’ll also recieve suggested goals over time as the Watch,鈥 according to Jay Blahnik, Apple鈥檚 director of Physical Fitness. We presume this is in part because, according to Blahnik, the Watch will also be able to 鈥渕easure intensity” via a custom sensor. Nobody at Apple has described this in greater detail, nor did the company elucidate how this works in Monday’s press event. Our best guess is that Apple鈥檚 proactively merging accelerometer data with heart-rate tracking, enabling the Watch to determine when you鈥檙e getting a whole-body workout (like CrossFit), and when you’re going for a run. These details should help set both suggested goals and recovery time, calories burned, and more.听
Ultimately, Apple says they鈥檒l be able to provide prescriptive fitness advice. But to do that, the device needs to be able to interpret data accurately, not just collect it. By monitoring active heart rate over time (many weeks of workouts), resting heart rate while sleeping, and the wearer鈥檚 fitness goals (a marathon in three months), the Watch should be able to come up with custom workouts, which will probably be further harnessed via third-party apps. 听听
But there鈥檚 currently a gap between regular trackers (which poke you when you鈥檝e been inactive) and machines that can learn and teach. We don鈥檛 expect Apple to necessarily get that magic right out of the gate. No one else has.听
But here鈥檚 the distinction that鈥檚 given Apple an advantage before鈥攖he watch is just a platform. The iPhone didn鈥檛 change the phone industry just because it looked and performed better than other options (although that helped). Rather, Apple ensured that third-party app makers could explore unique and creative software ideas for the device.听
App developers have told us privately that it鈥檚 easier to work on Apple apps because of the single platform鈥攖he iPhone. Compare that to Android, where developers have to create products to work on a huge range of hardware. That鈥檚 why so many apps debut for Apple phones first, and then later migrate to Android.
So we expect fitness app producers are already scrambling to roll out new tools for the Watch, with the idea that if they get to use key health metrics, they can write code to interpret your fitness data for your particular sport. And, in a perfect world, because Apple鈥檚 Health App already enables you to feed from other trackers (say, a Garmin or Magellan cycling head unit), there鈥檒l be increased interplay between apps on the watch and on the phone.听
For instance, Strava announced Monday that it’s going to deliver a version of its app specifically for the Watch that will include time and distance, but also haptic notifications when you’re approaching ride or run segments stored in the Strava database. Strava鈥檚 Apple Watch announcement is especially germane to cyclists, who shouldn鈥檛 be eyeballing their phones mid-ride anyway. A glance at a wrist is safer.
Granted, there鈥檚 other hardware on the market that uses third-party apps. Take Pebble, which probably offers the best suite of . If you鈥檙e running Snocru on the Pebble, that鈥檚 what you鈥檙e seeing. You’re not beaming info to Snocru and only seeing the info after the fact on your phone.听
More fitness-focused brands, such as Garmin and Suunto, work with third-party apps, too, but in Garmin鈥檚 case, they鈥檙e still in the early stages of integration. With听Suunto (at least that we鈥檝e seen so far), the apps are subservient to the platform鈥攖here鈥檚 no whole-scale real-estate takeover of your watch face. Sure, Suunto lets you immediately upload tracked workouts to Strava,听but the integration happens after the fact, not during your work out, as Strava鈥檚 Apple Watch integration already highlights.
Now for our misgivings about the Watch. 听
First, battery life. Cook mentioned he recharges his watch every night, and said today the watch’s battery lasts 18 hours. So your Badwater Ultra might be a test of both your endurance and your watch’s.
Also, the Apple Watch鈥檚 key functions all happen through Bluetooth/WiFi and its connection with an iPhone or a network. So you can go for a run with just the Watch and it will store basic heart-rate data, but鈥攗nlike with a wearable like Wahoo鈥檚 TickrX鈥攜ou won鈥檛 have onboard GPS if you leave the phone at home. (Note that this is the case with Pebble, too, and with other advanced fitness trackers.) 听
There鈥檚 also the relatively high price, which starts at $349. The Moto 360 is $250. The Withings Activit茅 is $450, while the new Activit茅 Pop will only be $150, although it doesn鈥檛 have a built-in heart-rate monitor.
The Watch is going to be a luxury item, and it’s going to take time for it to become a breakthrough fitness device. But our bet is that once you own one, you鈥檒l continue to wear it, and that alone should provide fitness insights that other 鈥渨earables鈥 won鈥檛 yield鈥攂ecause they鈥檙e not comfortable or good-looking enough for 24/7 use.听
And over time we鈥檙e counting on incredible fitness apps debuting for the Watch, ones that will yield a broader health picture for millions of wearers. That part鈥攎illions of wearers鈥攊s really the key. Because enough fitness-focused users will drive innovation that makes or breaks the Watch as the ultimate wearable.听