Yeah, there is a lot to be said for the older way of making boots. Mind you, I think modern boots have a lot of advantages聴they聮re lighter and more comfortable than boots of years ago. But it聮s still hard to beat a good quality pair of all-leather boots.
The SundownersThe Sundowners ($200) certainly are classics. They聮ve been around for years. They聮re now available only with Gore-Tex booties, which may or may not be a problem for you. I also like the Panthers ($225), which have 2.8 mm leather uppers, a classic look, and liners that are part leather, part Cambrelle fabric.
still makes real old-school boots. Their SL M3s ($250) have silicon-impregnated one-piece leather uppers, flexible cuffs to keep out debris, Cambrelle liners, and Vibram soles. Very serious boots. And there is the Mountain Trail GTX ($200). A little lighter than the Scarpas, but still with full-grain leather uppers, Vibram soles, and Gore-Tex booties.
With boots such as these, you聮ll need to do some break-in. Wear them around the house, then around the block a few times, and then on a short hike or two. Shouldn聮t take long to get them to adapt nicely to your feet. Keep them clean, washing them after heavy use with running water and a soft brush. And use a good leather treatment, such as Waterproofing Wax ($8.50). With reasonable care, you should get many years of use out of your boots.