Colorado recorded last Friday and Saturday, which naturally made folks wonder听if the COVID-inspired was already contributing to a prophesied uptick in avalanche deaths.听
It鈥檚 not. It鈥檚 good policy not to weigh in on the specifics of avalanche accidents like slope angle, decision making, and cause of death until local avalanche centers and coroners compile their reports, and we鈥檒l honor that here. But we know enough鈥攁nd my reporting backs this up鈥攖o discard the premise that the Colorado victims were newbies. It would be hard to find three backcountry skiers with more experience.听
There are hundreds of nuanced human and environmental factors in every avalanche death, but the commonality in Colorado鈥檚 tragic weekend is听clear. All the skiers were skiing avalanche听terrain during a highly suspect start to winter. Even in the Mountain West, with its notoriously risky continental听snowpack that sees weak layers linger, early-season snowpacks can be especially deadly. This is true in the specific鈥擟olorado鈥檚 avalanche risk was 鈥渃onsiderable鈥 at the time of the accidents and hasn鈥檛 been this sketchy since听2012, which saw 11 avalanche deaths听in the state. And it鈥檚 also true as a generalization鈥攁ny avalanche on a thin new snowpack will likely drag you over rocks,听increasing听the risk of trauma. While it鈥檚 not universally true, deeper snowpacks tend to be less volatile when it comes to persistent weaknesses. By insulating weak layers from wild temperature swings, physically distancing skiers from hitting hidden triggers, and mechanically crushing weakness from听sheer听mass, deep snowpacks can (sometimes; we hope) make for more predictable backcountry travel.听
This is听extra relevant right now in the Rockies. Brian Lazar, deputy director of the Colorado Avalanche Information Center describes the conditions: 鈥淲e saw early snow in October, which is never good. That snow sat on the ground under blue skies and faceted鈥濃攖hink sugar snow鈥斺渜uite dramatically. When we started to get snow again it put a slab on top of that weak layer. Now we鈥檙e loading those slabs with more snow and skiers and they鈥檙e quite reactive. It鈥檚 a once-in-a-decade听type of instability.鈥澨
That sort听of early-season听snowpack isn鈥檛 conducive to skiing avalanche terrain. But year after year, more skiers are heading out into such environments.听
Something has changed, not with the world outside, but with us. My personal history as a backcountry skier is kind of illuminating. Back in the 1990s when I started regularly skiing in the backcountry, my touring season didn鈥檛 start until winter had established itself. I liked getting my ski legs under me on-area in December and January as I tuned into local avalanche advisories, asked questions, followed the weather, waited for the snowpack to deepen, and built a 鈥渟eason history鈥 of the snowpack. Maybe I鈥檇 head out the ski area gates and dig a pit before gliding back in or skiing some low angle snow. By February with the snowpack building to its apex, I鈥檇 gradually push into more consequential terrain as conditions allowed. That鈥檚 still largely how my Missoula friends and I approach the backcountry today.
That approach was never universal, nor is it universally correct. To be clear, outside the Rockies, or in good years within them, early-season听snow isn鈥檛 always so suspect. And regardless, as long as skiers have been in the backcountry, people have skied early. (There鈥檚 a feature near Crested Butte called Halloween Bowl because it historically offered early-season coverage鈥攁nd, on occasion, early-season avalanches.)听 But what鈥檚 changed is that today we have more backcountry skiers, and, this is my distinction, more people听who听socially identify as backcountry-only skiers. That dynamic sets up two more: first, says Karl Birkeland, the director听of the Forest Service鈥檚 , many of the low-angle听and more predictable slopes closer to trailheads are getting crowded and tracked up. That pushes more experienced skiers to bigger more consequential terrain perhaps earlier than they traditionally would have. 鈥淲e don鈥檛 have data to back this up,鈥澨齭ays Birkeland, 鈥渂ut it鈥檚 my personal experience that people are going out to ski bigger objectives earlier than they used to. They鈥檙e skiing terrain that they used to wait until springtime for. I don鈥檛听know why that鈥檚 the case. But I think what we鈥檙e observing anecdotally is true. Maybe it鈥檚 because I backcountry ski with my daughters now and I鈥檓 more aware of it. Or maybe it鈥檚 our new reality.鈥
There are other factors at play. The risks of backcountry skiing are less discernible than other sports. Crash your mountain bike, get maytagged in a whitewater hole, or take a whipper rock climbing and the feedback is consistent. After a few mistakes you know the outcomes. But avalanches don鈥檛 work that way. We go out in March and ski an avalanche path. It doesn鈥檛 avalanche. We鈥檙e positively rewarded all month. Then we head out the following December and it slides, possibly with lethal outcomes. Our mountains and our minds are full of slopes 鈥渢hat never slide,鈥 until they do.听
Sarah Carpenter, an instructor with and the co-owner of the attributes much of our backcountry decision making to this inconsistent feedback. 鈥淢ore users and social media also play a role,鈥 says Carpenter, who teaches in Jackson, 鈥渂ut it鈥檚 the inconsistent nature of avalanches that have shifted up the risk tolerance of mountain communities. In the Tetons I like to say that 鈥榗onsiderable鈥 is the new 鈥榤oderate.鈥 The more you ski those conditions and terrain without incident,听the more it skews your outlook.鈥 Research backs this up, says Carpenter. If you ask an experienced backcountry skier and a beginner to gauge the slope angle by eye, crucial for identifying avalanche terrain, seasoned skiers will underestimate the pitch, and novices will overestimate it.
None of this is to say that self-identifying听backcountry skiers need to adopt my approach to skiing. It鈥檚 easy for me to resist the call of early-season听touring鈥擨 lost a friend听to an early-season avalanche, and another friend was nearly paralyzed after crashing into early-season rocks鈥攂ut I wholly understand the desire. As does the Colorado Avalanche Center鈥檚 Lazar. He鈥檚 from Carbondale and sees it as another mountain town thing. 鈥淚t鈥檚 natural to want to transition from mountain biking directly to ski touring,鈥 he says. 鈥淭he muddy shoulder seasons can wear on you. You get pent up. But I think patience is prudent. You鈥檇 hate to end your season by hitting a rock.鈥 Or, it goes without saying but should be written anyway, triggering a potentially fatal avalanche.听
Foregoing your passion, though, is not the point of this story. Nor is it the message that the avalanche professionals I talked with wanted to relay.听Once you鈥檙e confident you can avoid rocks and stumps, there鈥檚 no need to delay the season further. You just have to be deliberate in your decision making. 鈥淵ou have to pick the appropriate terrain given the conditions at hand,鈥 says Birkeland. 鈥淓ven in considerable or high hazard you can find low-angle听meadows that are well clear of avalanche slopes. You can have a great day. And over time you can have a great season. The nice thing about avalanche conditions is that they eventually change.鈥澨